July 2, 2026
photo_pw/Depositphotos.com
What Can Amazon Prime Day Results Tell Us About the Current State of Shoppers?
In a comprehensive report outlining the results of this year’s Amazon Prime Day sale by Modern Retail’s Allison Smith, several interesting trends and statistics were brought to the fore.
First of all, the financial results were decidedly mixed. Adobe Analytics data suggested that 2026’s Amazon Prime Day sale — the first to take place in June — saw average household spend decline 9% from $156.37 last year to $143.45 this year. Conversely, spend reached a record-setting $26.4 billion, indicating that more people participated in the sale this year, despite declining baskets — as well as the fact that inflationary pressure may have naturally pushed total spend higher more broadly.
Second, it appears that U.S. shoppers are much more likely to be snagging up deals on everyday essentials, seeking value on items they would have purchased anyways rather than splurging on new tech or a nice-to-have. Consumers opted for replacement brush heads over new electric toothbrushes, and kitchen appliances, and sheets, blankets, and mattresses versus more gadgets.
“Consumers used the occasion to stock up on products like protein shakes, trash bags and cat treats. Only 14% of shoppers reported purchasing consumer electronics such as televisions and cell phones,” Smith wrote, citing Numerator data.
Prime Day results are in, and history was made AGAIN!
Amazon saw a 9.5% year-over-year growth in 2025 and a total of $26.4 billion in revenue. Not a typo!
Day one alone brought in $8.3 billion in U.S. online spend, up 5.3% from 2025's opening day.
Cheap is in! Over 69% of… pic.twitter.com/KhgcxtUohl
— Jon Elder (@BlackLabelAdvsr) July 1, 2026
Amazon Prime Day Sales for 2026 Showed a Few Interesting Signals
Other data points highlighted in the report:
- Conversion rates were higher as traffic dips: Envision Horizons data suggested that conversion rates attached to Amazon Prime Day saw an uptick of 19% YoY, despite traffic tumbling 8% — and total orders improved by a notable 10%. “Fewer people browsed, but the shoppers who did visit Amazon listings were more likely to check out,” Smith added.
- Returning customers showed softness: A second tidbit of Envision Horizons statistics showed that returning customers were responsible for 56% of sales attached to a brand already, a figure which had declined 15% from 2025.
- Amazon, Target, TikTok Shop, and Walmart may beat eating some of Amazon’s lunch: Counter sales put off by competitors could be cutting into Amazon’s potential sales ceiling. Liran Hirschkorn, founder of Incrementum Digital (working with ~100 brands), suggested that client sales improved by 66% versus the prior month, down from last year’s result of an 81% uptick. Hirschkorn pointed to comparison shopping across competitors’ sales as the likeliest culprit.
There’s also the issue of sales fatigue, as Modern Retail’s Jim Tierney detailed. With Amazon Prime Day, sales at Kohl’s and Staples, Target Circle Deal Days, and Walmart deals all happening at the same time last week, shoppers were flooded with retail offers and options. And it’s starting to show up in the numbers, according to analysts.
“Over the course of the past few ‘sales weeks’ by the major retailers, we have seen the potency wane,” Marshal Cohen, chief retail adviser at Circana, said.
“The sales have either matched the previous year or fallen below in units. Dollars remain slightly higher, but that is mostly due to higher costs,” Cohen added.
At the same time, shoppers are showing cognitive dissonance to some degree — indicating tiredness with endless sales, but no restraint when closing the household’s purse strings — and retailers are equally unlikely to slow their sales event cadence.
A material portion of most retailers’ sales are done with some level of discount, whether it’s a permanent markdown, limited time sale, loyalty discount or some other offer,” David Silverman, senior director of corporates at Fitch Ratings, said.
“Retailers adjust their approach to promotions over time based on data analytics to create excitement, compelling consumers to make purchases,” he concluded.
BrainTrust
Jeff Sward
Founding Partner, Merchandising Metrics
Mohamed Amer, PhD
Strategy Advisor, CEO & Co-Founder, BridgeCommAI
Neil Saunders
Managing Director, GlobalData
Recent Discussions
Discussion Questions
What can the third-party results issued around Amazon Prime Day tell us about the current state of the U.S. consumer? What conclusions or observations are you drawing?
Do you agree with the notion that shoppers, as a whole, are displaying cognitive dissonance by indicating sales fatigue while continuing to spend at said sales?
Poll
Loading …
Consumers are very receptive to deals and offers right now, which is why many retailers are running promotions. It’s also why Amazon had so many deals, including more than ever on essentials and everyday items. This is essentially a bid to capture a greater share of spending in a market where consumers are choiceful and volume growth is relatively flat.
Does discounting drive extra spending? It likely has something of an incremental effect because it can pull spending from non-retail areas. However, a lot of it is just about shuffling round when the spend is made and where it goes. The latter point is really the whole reason for discounting – retailers are trying to grab share from rivals.
Consumers may exhibit cognitive dissonance when they feel overwhelmed by constant sales but still participate in them for fear of missing out on discounts.Furthermore, consumers may prioritize budget constraints while making impulse purchases during sales events.Although consumers may verbally acknowledge sales fatigue, their actions demonstrate a conflicted desire to take advantage of perceived savings.
Third party? Well, OK, but whatever Amazon paid Mr. Elder for his boosterism was dutifully reciprocated (and if he did it for free, then I guess they really got their money’s worth!)
But my somewhat catty comments aside, the mixture of headline grabbing total sales going up, but average tickets going down, suggests Prime Days may be reaching a kind of maturity. That people buy mundane items, too, I won’t try to give macro-economic implications to (I’ll just stick with noting people will buy whatever is on sale)
Customers are responsive to retailers who step up with markedly noticeable sales, offers, and promotions. And Amazon is no different in this game with competitors. A deal equaling 12% off or 17% off isn’t nearly as impactful as a psychological win felt by buying at 20%, 30% or even 50% off. If every retailer is doing the former, then it’s mostly noise and consumers have a hard time distinguishing who stands out from the pack. Right now retailers and grocers all over the country are flat year over year, with some up low single digits, some down. So this is the time to make hay and commit to customers who are prioritizing their spend more than ever.
It’s very hard to read about these Prime Day results and be anything but flat out nervous about the current state of the US consumer. Average household spend was DOWN 9%. Average selling price plummeted 19%. Those two numbers are the headline, not the “history was made AGAIN” nonsense. A bouyant headline with the bad news buried in the post. Not cool. Oh, and conversion was up! No surprise. People were seeking deals on items they were going to purchase anyway. So they waited for Prime Day and shopped with very high intent. But with very constrained budgets. Helllloooooo. That’s not cheerful news. And then there’s the observation that major retailers are experiencing the potency wane from their sales weeks. That might be a lesson we could have taken from Macy’s about a decade ago concerning their One Day Sales.
Prime Day should not be read as a simple sign of customer confidence. It shows that customers are still willing to buy, but they are being much more selective about timing and value. Many shoppers are not spending freely. They are waiting for moments when the deal feels strong enough to justify the purchase.
That is the important signal for retailers. Big promotional events can perform well even when everyday demand is under pressure. Some of the sales may be purchases customers delayed until Prime Day, rather than truly incremental spending.
The retailers that win from here will be the ones that make value clear without depending too heavily on discounts. Prime Day shows that shoppers are still in the market, but they need a stronger reason to act.
The cognitive dissonance diagnosis is applied to the wrong patient. Average spend dropped 9% while conversion climbed 19% on lower traffic. That is a disciplined shopper who browses less, converts more, and buys what they need at the best available price. No contradiction there.
The deeper signal is what they are buying. Prime Day was built to put Echoes and flat-screens in homes. Consumers have converted it into a coupon day for protein shakes and cat treats. When your signature sales event trains shoppers to comparison-shop across Target, Walmart, and TikTok simultaneously, you have built a habit that works against your own membership flywheel. The cognitive dissonance belongs to the retailer.
Exactly. It’s not the customer who is confused. It’s the retailers…!!! Training shoppers to cross shop, indeed…!!!
Consumers didn’t convert it. Amazon did. Deliberately. Amazon actually wants consumers to buy protein shakes and cat treats. That’s the digital arena where Walmart is currently stronger and they’re weaker. They want the essentials and the grocery shop because it drives frequency and volume through their network and they can now service it profitably. Prime Day is simply used as a recruiting tool for this category.
Maybe Amazon did learn something powerful about the grocery business.
Good point about Amazon’s motives and agenda.
Prime Day should not be read only as a sign of consumer strength or weakness. The more useful question is whether it created new demand or simply moved planned purchases into a promotional window.
The headline number is impressive, but the underlying behavior tells a more cautious story: smaller baskets, more essentials, more comparison shopping across competing retail events, and more shoppers waiting for the right deal before acting. That is a disciplined consumer, not a confident one.
For retailers beyond Amazon, the operational implication is underappreciated. When every major player runs a competing event in the same window, the promotion stops being about inspiration and starts being about share capture. Some volume may be incremental, but a meaningful portion may simply be pulled forward from future weeks or shifted away from a competitor who might have captured it anyway.
The Circana point about promotional potency waning is what happens when the whole industry teaches shoppers to wait for the same discount moments.
The operating test that matters is not GMV or traffic. It is contribution margin. Did the event bring in profitable new demand? Did it clear the right inventory? Did it reinforce loyalty — or did it train customers to treat the regular price as a placeholder until the next discount cycle arrives?
My concern is that retailers may be celebrating promotional success while quietly eroding everyday price credibility. The winners will be those who use these events surgically — targeted value, specific inventory objectives, and loyalty reinforcement — rather than as a reflex response to whatever Amazon schedules.
This is a picture of the current economy. My take on this:
Spend per customer is down. Higher prices (all mentioned in the article) mean less money to spend.
The number of customers is up. Customers are looking for better prices, and therefore those who might not buy from Amazon as often are looking for retailers (like Amazon) that offer the best value in terms of price.
More Discussions
Is Unilever’s ‘An Influencer in Every ZIP Code’ Approach to Modern Retail Marketing a Smart Play?
Is Unilever’s large-scale engagement of influencer marketing a turning point in retail marketing?What Should Kroger Do With Giant Eagle After its Purchase Is Completed?
Kroger plans to leave most of Giant Eagle’s operations intact, for now.Retail Shift Workers Report High Happiness Levels, Survey Says, But How Can Frontline Employee Satisfaction Be Improved?
What’s your take on the data? What improvements can be made in terms of retail shift…
Consumers are very receptive to deals and offers right now, which is why many retailers are running promotions. It’s also why Amazon had so many deals, including more than ever on essentials and everyday items. This is essentially a bid to capture a greater share of spending in a market where consumers are choiceful and volume growth is relatively flat.
Does discounting drive extra spending? It likely has something of an incremental effect because it can pull spending from non-retail areas. However, a lot of it is just about shuffling round when the spend is made and where it goes. The latter point is really the whole reason for discounting – retailers are trying to grab share from rivals.
Consumers may exhibit cognitive dissonance when they feel overwhelmed by constant sales but still participate in them for fear of missing out on discounts.Furthermore, consumers may prioritize budget constraints while making impulse purchases during sales events.Although consumers may verbally acknowledge sales fatigue, their actions demonstrate a conflicted desire to take advantage of perceived savings.
Third party? Well, OK, but whatever Amazon paid Mr. Elder for his boosterism was dutifully reciprocated (and if he did it for free, then I guess they really got their money’s worth!)
But my somewhat catty comments aside, the mixture of headline grabbing total sales going up, but average tickets going down, suggests Prime Days may be reaching a kind of maturity. That people buy mundane items, too, I won’t try to give macro-economic implications to (I’ll just stick with noting people will buy whatever is on sale)
Customers are responsive to retailers who step up with markedly noticeable sales, offers, and promotions. And Amazon is no different in this game with competitors. A deal equaling 12% off or 17% off isn’t nearly as impactful as a psychological win felt by buying at 20%, 30% or even 50% off. If every retailer is doing the former, then it’s mostly noise and consumers have a hard time distinguishing who stands out from the pack. Right now retailers and grocers all over the country are flat year over year, with some up low single digits, some down. So this is the time to make hay and commit to customers who are prioritizing their spend more than ever.
It’s very hard to read about these Prime Day results and be anything but flat out nervous about the current state of the US consumer. Average household spend was DOWN 9%. Average selling price plummeted 19%. Those two numbers are the headline, not the “history was made AGAIN” nonsense. A bouyant headline with the bad news buried in the post. Not cool. Oh, and conversion was up! No surprise. People were seeking deals on items they were going to purchase anyway. So they waited for Prime Day and shopped with very high intent. But with very constrained budgets. Helllloooooo. That’s not cheerful news. And then there’s the observation that major retailers are experiencing the potency wane from their sales weeks. That might be a lesson we could have taken from Macy’s about a decade ago concerning their One Day Sales.
Prime Day should not be read as a simple sign of customer confidence. It shows that customers are still willing to buy, but they are being much more selective about timing and value. Many shoppers are not spending freely. They are waiting for moments when the deal feels strong enough to justify the purchase.
That is the important signal for retailers. Big promotional events can perform well even when everyday demand is under pressure. Some of the sales may be purchases customers delayed until Prime Day, rather than truly incremental spending.
The retailers that win from here will be the ones that make value clear without depending too heavily on discounts. Prime Day shows that shoppers are still in the market, but they need a stronger reason to act.
The cognitive dissonance diagnosis is applied to the wrong patient. Average spend dropped 9% while conversion climbed 19% on lower traffic. That is a disciplined shopper who browses less, converts more, and buys what they need at the best available price. No contradiction there.
The deeper signal is what they are buying. Prime Day was built to put Echoes and flat-screens in homes. Consumers have converted it into a coupon day for protein shakes and cat treats. When your signature sales event trains shoppers to comparison-shop across Target, Walmart, and TikTok simultaneously, you have built a habit that works against your own membership flywheel. The cognitive dissonance belongs to the retailer.
Exactly. It’s not the customer who is confused. It’s the retailers…!!! Training shoppers to cross shop, indeed…!!!
Consumers didn’t convert it. Amazon did. Deliberately. Amazon actually wants consumers to buy protein shakes and cat treats. That’s the digital arena where Walmart is currently stronger and they’re weaker. They want the essentials and the grocery shop because it drives frequency and volume through their network and they can now service it profitably. Prime Day is simply used as a recruiting tool for this category.
Maybe Amazon did learn something powerful about the grocery business.
Good point about Amazon’s motives and agenda.
Prime Day should not be read only as a sign of consumer strength or weakness. The more useful question is whether it created new demand or simply moved planned purchases into a promotional window.
The headline number is impressive, but the underlying behavior tells a more cautious story: smaller baskets, more essentials, more comparison shopping across competing retail events, and more shoppers waiting for the right deal before acting. That is a disciplined consumer, not a confident one.
For retailers beyond Amazon, the operational implication is underappreciated. When every major player runs a competing event in the same window, the promotion stops being about inspiration and starts being about share capture. Some volume may be incremental, but a meaningful portion may simply be pulled forward from future weeks or shifted away from a competitor who might have captured it anyway.
The Circana point about promotional potency waning is what happens when the whole industry teaches shoppers to wait for the same discount moments.
The operating test that matters is not GMV or traffic. It is contribution margin. Did the event bring in profitable new demand? Did it clear the right inventory? Did it reinforce loyalty — or did it train customers to treat the regular price as a placeholder until the next discount cycle arrives?
My concern is that retailers may be celebrating promotional success while quietly eroding everyday price credibility. The winners will be those who use these events surgically — targeted value, specific inventory objectives, and loyalty reinforcement — rather than as a reflex response to whatever Amazon schedules.
This is a picture of the current economy. My take on this:
Spend per customer is down. Higher prices (all mentioned in the article) mean less money to spend.
The number of customers is up. Customers are looking for better prices, and therefore those who might not buy from Amazon as often are looking for retailers (like Amazon) that offer the best value in terms of price.