DISCUSSION

Can AI Customer Service Actually Replace Humans?

Written by Nicholas Morine

In a report for CNBC, journalist Kevin Williams outlined the current struggles that AI customer service bots and call centers are having in satisfying shopper demands, despite several industries adopting these solutions at scale.

Noting that while the promise of AI call centers and chatbots is enticing for many operations looking to slash costs, deflection -- rather than resolution -- is often a part of the game as it stands, with customer satisfaction often being the metric left behind.

“I hate AI customer service chatbots,” said Californian shopper Carmen Smith, as quoted by Williams.

“It seems that no matter what, they all will either point you to some type of FAQs list or repeat information you’ve already tried and found lacking,” Smith said. “I hate dealing with them, but a lot of companies use them nowadays, alas. I’d rather speak to a human being."

Qualtrics data cited by the report indicated that ~20% of consumers who had engaged with AI customer service agents received zero benefit from the interaction, a failure rate four times higher than AI usage more broadly.

“Too many companies are deploying AI to cut costs, not solve problems, and customers can tell the difference,” said Isabelle Zdatny of Qualtrics, author of the 2026 Customer Experience Trends Report.

Other notable trends captured by Williams:

  • AI systems often reflect leadership intent in terms of refunds, reduction of escalation, and call times. While human agents may exert some degree of perceived compassion or rapport with customers, ultimately an argument can be made that they, too, are simply scripted.
  • A frequent complaint regarding AI customer service centers or solutions is that they make shoppers feel as if they trapped in a loop via automation. This presents a frustrating, annoying (or worse) barrier.
  • AI customer service may become the de facto standard: Zendesk CEO Tom Eggemeier underscored his belief that within three years, half of all online customer service interactions will be handled by AI bots, with this number rising to 80% within the next five years.

If AI Customer Service Agents Are the Future, Proponents Say There Are Upsides (But Do Consumers Agree?)

On the other hand, some proponents argue that AI deflection can be valuable to protect high-burnout workers, mitigate turnover, and reduce mental health strains. Further, they may be able to simply deliver the necessary "no" that a human may struggle with or hedge against.

“If two people are arguing about a refund and the law says it is not available, a judge would adjudicate rather than argue continuously back and forth. That is often what happens in agent-to-unhappy-customer scenarios,” Terra Higginson, principal research director at Info-Tech Research Group, said.

“This makes the process about enforcing rules and regulations rather than making refunds difficult... without the arguing and back-and-forth strain of being yelled at for following company rules," she added, pivoting to also highlight that obstructing valid refunds was not the goal of an ethical or effective AI agent.

Another recent survey seems to indicate that consumers aren't as in love with AI customer service as those deploying them. According to CX Dive, which pulled figures from a 2025 HubSpot and SurveyMonkey survey capturing the thoughts of 1,800 business leaders and 15,000 consumers worldwide, a majority (53%) of shoppers "actively dislike or hate AI's use in service interactions."

"This widespread aversion suggests that current AI applications often fail to meet customer expectations for empathy, nuance and genuine connection,” said Zoe Padgett, senior research scientist at SurveyMonkey.

“Rather than seeing AI as a helpful tool, many customers perceive it as a barrier, leading to frustration and a feeling that their unique concerns aren’t truly understood.”

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more