DISCUSSION

Is AI Fatigue Setting In as Retailers Struggle To Scale or Incorporate Tools?

Written by Nicholas Morine

Artificial intelligence (AI) has captured the imagination of many business sectors, including retail. During this year's National Retail Federation Big Show held in New York City, AI tools — and topics ranging from gen AI to agentic AI, and their use cases — were the unambiguous throughline dominating so many discussions.

Now, as Fortune pointed out, "AI fatigue" could be setting in at the corporate level.

Citing data from S&P Global Market Intelligence, Fortune writer Sage Lazzaro indicated that the share of companies that had nixed the bulk of their AI initiatives had surged from 17% in 2024 to 42% so far this year. Perhaps even more striking, data suggested that the average company had scrapped nearly half (46%) of its AI proofs of concept instead of executing them.

What's more, Lagazzo pointed to a Quantum Workplace study which painted a somewhat counterintuitive picture of AI incorporation into enterprise workflow: Employees who rated themselves as frequent AI users reported higher levels of work burnout (45%) than those who infrequently (38%) or even never (35%) leverage AI for work-related tasking.

Lagazzo quoted Erik Brown, the AI and emerging tech lead at consulting firm West Monroe, as to why this trend appears to be growing in stature in 2025.

“Anytime [that] a market, and everyone around you, is beating you over the head with a message on a trending technology, it’s human nature — you just get sick of hearing about it,” Brown said.

“I think it’s so easy with any new technology, especially one that’s getting the attention of AI, to just lead with the tech first. That’s where I think a lot of this fatigue and initial failures are coming from," Brown added.

TechCrunch provided a parallel data point when referencing recent transaction data from fintech company Ramp in a June 9 report. In that report, the outlet noted that Ramp's AI index — "which estimates the U.S. business adoption rate of AI products by drawing on Ramp’s card and bill pay data" — saw a flattening rate of adoption as of May 2025 following 10 consecutive months of growth.

In May, 49% of large businesses had incorporated AI in some fashion (as well as 44% of medium-sized companies, and 37% of smaller businesses). And although TechCrunch AI editor Kyle Wiggers did point out the incomplete portrait being painted by Ramp's AI index — which draws from corporate spend data sourced from ~30,000 companies), he did note that there was one general truth in evidence.

"But it’s certainly true that businesses are beginning to realize that there’s a limit to what today’s AI can do," Wiggers concluded.

Retailers Struggle To Scale AI, Despite Widespread Experimentation

And according to a May 30 blog post from Valtech, citing information gleaned from a retail roundtable with Google Cloud, retailers are also exhibiting a halting of progress in terms of scaling AI tools.

The cornerstone data point provided by the consulting agency: While nearly 85% of retailers are currently experimenting with AI, only a fraction of that number (a sizable minority of 15%-20%) have "scaled it in a meaningful way."

The three primary causes of failure-to-launch when it comes to artificial intelligence tools, as outlined by Valtech? A lack of clear ownership, meaning that AI pilot projects often originate in tech or data teams but are missing an experienced and capable business lead who can take ownership and drive value from the tool; a lack of repeatability, which sees so many successful pilots display early promise but then fizzle out due to a lack of designed scalability; and unclear or fuzzy metrics, because without useful feedback loops based on a constant flow of data or valuable input, there's very little incentive to continue deployment.

Matt Hildon, retail portfolio director at Valtech, laid the majority of the blame for failed AI scaling in retail at the foot of individual businesses who weren't prepared to execute.

“The tech is ready. The business often isn’t," Hildon said, somewhat arguing against Wiggers' position.

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more