DISCUSSION

BrainTrust Query: Managed Scarcity

Written by Guest contributor
Commentary by Ted Hurlbut, Principal of Hurlbut & Associates

For a year now, independent retailers of all shapes and sizes have been struggling with weak sales, deep markdowns and the question of how they'll ever be able to get customers to pay full price again. At the same time, they've drawn down inventories to align stock levels with sales, reduce markdown exposure and maintain positive cash flow. Throughout, as inventories have been reduced, there's also been the hope that lower stock levels would begin to put a floor beneath prices.

Last month, The New York Times noted how luxury retailers such as Saks, Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom are working on sustaining full retails through a conscious strategy of limiting quantity.

Burton M. Tansky, president and chief executive of the Neiman Marcus Group, told the Times, "We've told our customers that the availability is less than they're used to seeing in the stores. We've suggested that it would be prudent to shop early."

"We're out of stock on a number of hot items people want," Stephen I. Sadove, chairman and chief executive of Saks, said. "Our associates are telling people, 'If you want this item in your size, we only have three of them, we only have two.'"

Most likely, these retailers have actually planned for slight sales decreases, given the economic environment. But their sales plan is composed of more significant unit sales decreases combined with a recovery in average selling prices. The impact of such a plan, however, would not be slight. Higher average selling prices lead to greater margin percentages, which on a plan calling for a slight top line decrease will generate a nice increase on the margin line.

This is important for independent retailers, who tend to specialize in discretionary merchandise, and who have been struggling to command full retails and full margins. In an environment where significant top line increases just don't appear to be in the cards, a strategy of managed scarcity -- of planning for lower units sales offset by higher average selling prices -- makes a lot of sense for many independent retailers.

The article was followed by challenging November sales figures for luxury department stores. Comparable store sales were down 26.1 percent at Saks, and 7.5 percent at Neiman Marcus. Nordstrom, able to buck the trend, was up 2.2 percent.

What to make of all this? My reading is that the strategy of managed scarcity was not enough to overcome continued weak demand and consumer resistance to full retails. Limited supply did not lead to higher prices; rather, higher prices led to weak unit sales.

These November sales results are a key leading indicator for independent retailers. They suggest that as we move into 2010, the macro-economics will still be weak and consumers will still hold the upper hand. Skillful inventory management will remain vitally important, and cash flow will remain of paramount concern.

Discussion Questions: What do you think of the efforts by many luxury retailers to stem markdown pressures and regain full-price selling by purposely limiting quantities? Should independent retailers pursue this strategy? Is it too soon for such a strategy for both luxury chains and independents?

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more