BrainTrust Query: Will the iPhone take the market by giving customers what they want?
I just got a new cell phone - a Motorola Krzr on a Verizon plan. Based on my experience so far, Apple has an open field with its highly (to put it mildly) anticipated new iPhone, due for release on June 29th. (According to the New York Times, and others, the iPhone's been dubbed "The God Machine" - by whom, is unclear.)
The whole Apple mantra is centered on providing an outstanding user experience by making technology useful and easy to use. It seems that Verizon regards the cell phone as a tool for marketing their services and whether it is useful or convenient to use are immaterial.
I had a Verizon phone already and the only reason I changed was because my contract had been expired for three months and my new phone would be "free". Anticipating the learning curve, I waited until a convenient time to make the switch. I had pictures on my old phone, custom ring tones and, of course, my address book. My first disappointment was to learn that only my address book could be transferred to the new phone.
The pictures are gone unless I want to upload and download them again to the new phone (for only a small fee). And I won't be able to load the custom ring tones via email the way I had done with my old phone. Apparently that "bug" in the old software has been fixed. Ring tones are now only available by buying them from one of the service companies who no doubt pay Verizon some kind of fee.
I have an MP3 player... I use it to listen to radio programs on topics like security software, the economy and, of course, Car Talk. I thought my new cell phone was going to eliminate the need for the MP3 player because it promised to let me download music files etc., but apparently that's only the case if they are digitally protected. I also use the MP3 player to record notes for later follow up. The phone promised to do this too, and it does. The catch is that the files are in a proprietary format that cannot be played on my PC.
Oh yeah, and the "free" phone required a $30 "music package" to make the connection with my PC. This connection depends on a custom Motorola USB cable that contains some type of special circuit that is detectable by the software. So much for open standards.
Discussion Questions: Is it so difficult for product manufacturers to design around the "consumer experience" as their primary focus? Will iPhone be able to take the market by merely "giving customers what they want?"
[Author's commentary] Of course, Apple will be somewhat dependent on their service partner, AT&T, to assist in fulfilling all the promises being made. AT&T's under the helm of new CEO Randall Stephenson. The iPhone deal is being hailed as a real coupe for the telecom company, but will be piled on top of a busy transitional agenda. According to Stephenson, as interviewed by InformationWeek: "Our biggest challenge as a company is to ensure that our customers really understand what the new AT&T is all about. We are the most complete communications and entertainment provider for the way people live - and that starts with wireless. When people recognize that, we win."
So, on the one hand, he seems to understand the need for consumer centricity, but on the other...huge branding and organizational challenges to deal with. And reportedly, the iPhones will be sold at AT&T retail locations. Will associates be able to match the level of service at Apple Stores? Should be an interesting partnership.
Discussion Thread0
The RetailWire Daily
One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.
Want to know more? Learn more