DISCUSSION

Can Target Keep Slashing Prices Without Losing What Makes it Special?

Written by Nicholas Morine

With Target fully in the midst of a winning turnaround effort, according to its most recent Q2 earnings report, it may seem like the perfect time to push a little harder on its scale to drive even deeper shopper attraction to its stores and brand.

The company announced two recent plays to do exactly that, one in tune with the approach of the holiday season – slashing the price of almost 2,000 SKUs – and another in a bit of a branding foray outside of its usual playbook.

"Guests are looking ‌for ⁠great products at an incredible value, and that's an important part of what we aim to deliver every day," said Target's chief merchandising officer, Cara Sylvester, per Reuters.

This round of price decreases largely centers around apparel and bedding, with the former category seeing the assortment take on a discount of up to 20% versus last year’s pricing and the latter averaging sticker prices 15% more modest than a year prior.

Reuters also pointed out that Target had been cutting price tags for some time now under the leadership of CEO Michael Fiddelke.

When Fiddelke first assumed the role in February of this year, he spoke to the principles behind his leadership at the helm of this turnaround.

“And while we have real work to do, we are clear on who we are, our unique place in retail and in the hearts of our guests. We are equally clear on the opportunity in front of us. Our guests want great design, real value and experiences that delight,” he wrote, placing emphasis on placing Target between the low-cost leadership exemplified by players such as Walmart and the pure luxury space.

Could extensive moves at promotional pricing, and even everyday-low-pricing, end up pushing shopper perception of Target away from the third-position (between value and luxury) cache it is ostensibly seeking?

Target Also Experimenting With Localization Efforts in Certain Instances

Tangentially and also experimentally, Target has also expanded its lineup of locations which eschew the brand’s stereotypical red branding in favor of a more local color palette and aesthetic. A new design attached to its newly opened location in the Hamptons – Bridgehampton, New York – boasts a millennial gray color scheme rather than the customary crimson.

“Although the design elements of the Bridgehampton store reflect the specific character and requirements of the surrounding community, it is not the only Target store that deviates from its traditional red branding. The company’s Silverthorne store in Colorado and its South Lake Tahoe store in California also have specific exterior elements that consider the location of the store,” Retail Dive senior editor Kaarin Moore wrote.

Questions for further discussion:

  • In your opinion, is it possible that Target could end up slashing prices so often, and being so focused on value offering, that it becomes perceived as primarily a discount retailer? Why or why not?

  • Can Target strengthen its value proposition without diminishing the style and design differentiation that sets it apart from Walmart et al.?

  • Do you think Target is on the right path more broadly? And are these experiments simply A-B tests, or something more? What advice would you give to leadership at this juncture?

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more