DISCUSSION

Indestructible Crocs Facing Destruction

Written by George Anderson
By Bernice Hurst, Contributing Editor, RetailWire

One of the more challenging challenges set by Donald Trump for a group of celebrities last year was a campaign to encourage Croc lovers to ditch their footwear. Based on the assumption that they could not be destroyed, the idea was to pass them on to poorer people so those who could afford them would buy replacements.

So reports The Times in the U.K., quoting a Seattle fund manager who was surprised that his wife, rather than he, was able to figure out the reason for the task. "They had saturated the market. They wanted to stimulate demand by getting people to get rid of their old Crocs," he said.

Launched at a Florida boat show in 2002, the indestructible shoes were widely agreed to be ugly but fantastically comfortable. By the time the business floated in 2006, the $200 million raised made it the biggest initial public offering in shoe history, according to The Times' report.

But despite buying an accessories company and looking for other new products, Crocs remained a single line business and eventually found that there were simply no new customers around.

Sam Poser, an analyst at Sterne Agee, believes that the problem lies in Crocs' failure to evolve or extend their lines. The fact that they are so widely available, and easily copied, has not helped. By comparison, he believes Ugg shoes have a brighter future as their owner has controlled distribution and come up with variations. Another analyst noted, Uggs wear out, Crocs don't.

John Duerden, a former Reebok executive hired to revive the business, argued in his blog that they "are perhaps the perfect product for a world in which value and simplicity are replacing avarice and over-consumption."
While deciding whether to introduce this discussion, though, RetailWire editor-in-chief George Anderson recalled hearing Paco Underhill say that as a brand marketer or retailer you really should never look to have a "cool" product. The problem with cool products, he explained, is that they eventually become un-cool and suffer a demise that is in direct proportion or worse than the success they achieved in becoming identified as cool in the first place -- a lesson that Crocs may or may not be able to learn at this stage.

Discussion questions: Where did Crocs go wrong and what can it do to turn itself around? Is there any way a one-product company can succeed long term? When a company knows its products are trendy, what advance steps should they be taking to assure long-term success?

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more