Junk Mail Tarnishes Direct Mail
By Tom Ryan
Consumers 65 and older are targeted with the most unwanted direct mail, according to a second quarter survey conducted by stopthejunkmail.com and Harman Research Inc. More than 40 percent of individuals surveyed were 65 years old.
Of the total respondents, 88 percent agreed they received too much unsolicited mail and approximately 49 percent agreed that junk mail has a negative impact on the environment. Direct mail's "worst offenders" were banks (cited by 41 percent), followed by catalogs (35 percent). The report said that the top-10 catalog "opt outs" - or cancellation requests - were for Frontgate, Ballard Designs, Home Decorators Collection, Pottery Barn, Travel Smith, Restoration Hardware, The Company Store, Soft Surroundings, Linensource and Victoria's Secret.
Regarding catalogs, 41.1 percent said they would rather shop online than receive catalogs; 37.8 percent said they would rather receive special catalogs only once or twice a year with updates via e-mail; and 60 percent agreed that special or sales editions were a waste because not enough changes are included since the last catalog. Asked how often they want to see catalogs, 27 percent said once a month, 26 percent said once every three months, 19 percent said once every six months, and 28 percent said never.
Not surprisingly, a separate survey around credit cards found that direct mail campaigns are losing their effectiveness. In 1998, credit card issuers could count on a response rate of 1.2 percent to the offers for new cards that they sent out, but the projected response rate this year is only 0.28 percent, according to the study by Cardbeat, a market research report for the credit card industry.
The study found that direct mail campaigns are still highly effective - 42 percent of respondents said they signed up for their newest credit card because of a piece of mail. But only 26 percent opened any offers that arrived in their mailbox with nearly half reporting they do not open any credit card solicitations.
"Our data shows that most consumers do not enjoy receiving card solicitations in the mail," said Cardbeat's managing editor, Megan Bramlette, in a statement. "In fact, about 14 percent say that they are overwhelmed by the number of mail solicitations that they receive."
Discussion Questions: Are direct mail campaigns losing their effectiveness because of the sheer number of pieces being sent out? In what ways do direct mail and catalog efforts have to be reconfigured to avoid being perceived as junk mail? Can you name some retailers doing a good job avoiding junk-mail status in their direct mail or catalog efforts?
Discussion Thread0
The RetailWire Daily
One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.
Want to know more? Learn more