When Does Price Pack Architecture Become Shrinkflation?
PepsiCo is selling Lay’s potato chips in many different-sized bags ranging from 50 cents to about $5. The increased smaller-size packages promise to entice snack lovers seeking less-expensive options.
A Wall Street article noted that Campbell’s and Mondelez are also adding smaller snack packages to stress affordability. Costco now sells eight-packs of muffins for $6.99 versus its traditional 12-pack for $9.99 for similar reasons.
“Consumers are going into small pack sizes to optimize their absolute budget,” Mondelez CFO Luca Zaramella told the WSJ.
A side benefit is smaller-size offerings tend to support “higher profit margins,” according to the report.
One risk with shrinking package sizes is being accused of shrinkflation, or when businesses reduce the size or quantity of their products while charging the same, or an even higher, price.
Shrinkflation became a buzzword in 2022 as brands began shrinking the packages of everything from toilet paper to yogurt and corn chips as inflation spiked. Many consumers have become suspicious of retailers profiteering from packaging changes.
A survey of 1,200 US. consumers by Purdue University’s Center for Food Demand Analysis and Sustainability (CFDAS) from October 2024 found 82% think shrinkflation is a common practice used by food companies. A further 76% believe it is a result of trying to increase profits even when costs are not rising.
However, brands have been reducing packaging sizes for reasons beyond affordability over the last 15 years as part of “price pack architecture” strategies, as profiled in a 2024 episode of NPR’s “Planet Money” podcast. The practice refers to brands offering a portfolio of packages and prices to reach different consumers and buying occasions.
Reasons For Smaller Package Sizing Varies, But Will Consumers Blame Shrinkflation?
Packages may become smaller to meet the needs of consumers for on-the-go occasions, lunch snacking, or those working on portion control. The smaller can of soda or mini pack of snacks may offer a trial size or opening price point, or act as an impulse purchase at checkout.
At the other end of the spectrum, family-size packs can support more of a value offering. Walmart offers Coca-Cola in increments as small as a 7.5 fluid oz. cans in a 10-pack to as large as a 3-liter bottle.
“I absolutely think there’s a tremendous opportunity in the U.S. marketplace to leverage greater pack diversity,” said Coca-Cola CEO James Quincey, in late 2023, on an earnings call.
For retailers, one challenge is finding shelf space for the variety of packaging sizes and price points and avoiding SKU proliferation.
NPR's co-host, Amanda Aronczyk, was uncertain of the consumer benefits of price pack architecture.
She said, “On one hand, this is a story about companies bending over backwards to give us what we want in exactly the right quantities in exactly the right packages, which sounds like a win for consumers. But on the other hand, price pack architecture has also been one of the main ways that companies over the last decade have been able to squeeze more and more profits out of us, just by putting the same old stuff in a different package.”
Discussion Thread0
The RetailWire Daily
One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.
Want to know more? Learn more
