Should AI Be Used To Respond to Customer Reviews?
For the second year in a row, BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey in a blind test found that a majority of consumers prefer responses to online reviews from businesses created by AI rather than a human.
BrightLocal’s annual study of online reviews, in its 15th year, continued to find significant benefits to businesses responding to online customer reviews. Of the just over 1,000 U.S. adults surveyed, 89% were more likely to shop at a business that responds to all reviews, whether positive or negative. About 56% were more hesitant to shop at a business that didn't respond to reviews.
In its 2024 survey, BrightLocal first introduced a blind test asking its consumer panel to choose a preferred response to a review for a restaurant — one was a real business owner’s response, sourced from Google, and the second was generated using an AI prompt in ChatGPT. Of the respondents, 58% preferred the ChatGPT-generated response versus 42% for the human response.
In the 2025 survey, the blind test explored a response by a vet clinic and saw the same results — the ChatGPT-generated response was preferred to the human response, 58% to 42%, respectively.
Here are the two review responses provided in this year's survey:
- First response (written by a human): “Denise, we appreciate the confidence you have in Dr. Evans and the entire team at Animal Hospital. We value senior dogs as much as young pups and do everything in our power to keep them all healthy. Thanks so much for your kind remarks and terrific five-star review. It means [so] much to us.”
- Second response (written by AI): “Thank you so much, Denise, for your kind words and for trusting us with the care of your senior pup. Dr. Evans and our entire team truly enjoy being here for you both, and we’re so happy to hear that you feel comfortable with the care we provide. Supporting pets and their families is what we’re all about, and it means the world to us to know we’ve earned your trust. We look forward to many more happy visits with you and your furry companion! Warm regards, Animal Hospital”
BrightLocal said the results contrast with other findings in the report showing that consumers might think reviews written by AI are fake. When asked how they tell if a customer review is fake, 46% of respondents said if it “feels like it was written by AI.”
“Are consumers just less aware of what AI really is than they thought?” BrightLocal speculated in its 2025 study. “As we mused in the 2024 report, it’s hard to say exactly why consumers might prefer this response over the other. Perhaps some consumers felt that the response in option two was more heartfelt, which, when we’re talking about our beloved pets, makes sense! With these findings two years in a row, it does show that AI tools can be a useful aid to help local businesses and marketers respond to their reviews with unique content, at scale.”
A survey of 700 U.S. adults in January 2024 from SEMrush, a company specializing in online visibility management, similarly found that AI-generated content was preferred in blind tests by humans over human-generated content for numerous advertising functions, including social media posts, social media ads, and product descriptions.
The use of AI would be a significant time saver for business owners as well as possibly a better option than outsourcing responses to online customer reviews to a junior employee. Sprout Social in a blog entry noted that AI can provide auto-generated replies to online reviews that reflect the sentiment of the customer’s review and can be tailored to sound “friendlier, shorter, [and] more professional."
However, surveys show that while people are growing more aware and comfortable with AI, many still have trust issues and want transparency.
A Nielsen survey of 6,000 U.S. adults on AI in media found that 55% felt uncomfortable on websites that rely heavily on AI-generated articles and stories, according to Forbes.
A Yahoo-commissioned poll of over 1,200 U.S. consumers and more than 350 U.S. advertisers from fall 2023 found that while 77% of advertisers view AI positively, only 38% of consumers shared this sentiment. The study also found that 53% of consumers were unfamiliar with AI use in advertisements.
Yet, Yahoo’s study found that AI-generated ads with noticed disclosures significantly boosted brand perceptions and provided a 47% lift in ad appeal, a 73% lift in ad trustworthiness, and a 96% lift in overall trust for the company.
As far as customer reviews, a recent Yelp-commissioned survey of 2,350 Yelp review readers found that a whopping 88% oppose AI-generated reviews on review platforms.
Discussion Thread0
The RetailWire Daily
One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.
Want to know more? Learn more
