DISCUSSION

Are Thrift Stores the Ultimate Treasure Hunt?

Written by Tom Ryan

While online resale marketplaces such as ThredUp, The RealReal, and Poshmark are seeing healthy growth, Goodwill, consignment shops, and other physical thrift stores also appear to be thriving -- and benefit by offering even more of a treasure hunt and social experience.

Thrift stores have posted consistent double-digit foot traffic growth in the second half through November, compared to a 2.5% traffic decline on average to traditional apparel stores -- and a meager 0.3% increase found at luxury stores -- according to Placer.ai.

Placer.ai, which specializes in location intelligence and foot traffic data analytics, said in a blog entry that the findings suggest “economic pressure, sustainability concerns, and the appeal of the treasure-hunt experience are pushing more consumers toward secondhand shopping.”

Placer.ai further found that while traditionally catering to lower-income shoppers, the thrift channel is seeing more higher-income consumers trading down. The company said, “These trends suggest that the thrift segment is benefiting from a more price-sensitive consumer base, as its trade area continues to broaden to include a greater share of higher-income households.”

Physical thrift stores benefit from many of the same trends driving the appeal of online resale platforms. According to OfferUp's Recommerce Report 2025, the top reasons for buying secondhand are to save money, cited by 79%; followed by finding something unique, 54%. Sustainability is also often cited as a driver of resale.

Can Other Retailers Borrow Some 'Treasure Hunt' Magic From Thrift Shops?

However, a recent survey from Savers Value Village, the largest for-profit thrift operator in North America, found treasure hunting to be a “consistent draw” for in-store thrifting. The survey found half of thrift shoppers started thrifting because of the potential treasure hunt, with 80% saying they enjoy the treasure hunt of searching for items.

In-store thrifting was also found to be a “social pastime” shared with friends and family. Half of thrifters indicated they consider thrift shopping a social activity they like to do with others, with ~90% saying they spend more than 30 minutes in a store when thrifting.

In-store thrifting also enables a shopper to check the quality and fit of an item.

A Business of Fashion article from earlier this year, entitled “The Future of Online Resale Is Offline,” found Fashionphile, Rebag, and The RealReal opening stores -- or partnering with department stores or other retailers -- to reach thrifters.

“You can’t replicate the treasure hunt experience online,” Cynthia Power, founder of Molte Volte, a consultancy that focuses on fashion reuse and recycling, told Business of Fashion. “If you’re in person and you find the right pre-owned piece that feels like it’s one of a kind, that conversion rate will be so much higher than if you find something online.”

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more