Google Search
Photo by Firmbee.com on Unsplash

Has Google Raised the Search Bar on Online Personalization?

Google is piloting new product discovery elements designed to give users a more personalized shopping experience, including enabling ratings on products.

Among the new personalized shopping tools highlighted in a blog entry from Sean Scott, Google’s VP/GM of consumer shopping:

  • Style recommendations: When searching for certain apparel, shoes, or accessories, such as “men’s polo shirts,” U.S. shoppers signed in via mobile browsers and the Google app will see a section labeled “style recommendations.” Similar to rating systems on Netflix or Tinder, they can rate merchandise options with a thumbs up or thumbs down, or a swipe right or left, to gain personalized results. Preferences are remembered. Scott wrote in the blog entry, “So when you’re looking for, say, men’s polo shirts again, you’ll see personalized style recommendations based on what you liked in the past and products you interacted with.”
  • Brand preferences: U.S. shoppers searching for apparel, shoes, or accessories on mobile browsers, desktops, or the Google app can specify which brands they’d like in their searches. Once chosen, options from these brands appear instantly. Preferences around the brand can be further fine-tuned.
  • Generative AI for product search: Google’s AI image generation tool for shopping is now available to all U.S. users who have opted into Search Generative Experience (SGE) within Search Labs. If searching for a specific item, like a “colorful quilted spring jacket,” users tap “Generate images” after their search to see photorealistic options matching their preferences. Since users’ search descriptions often vary, image-driven searches can help you “shop for apparel styles similar to whatever you had in mind.” Scott wrote, “For instance, someone might call something boxy, while another might call it oversized.”
  • Virtual try-on: Google’s virtual try-on (VTO) tool, accessible in the U.S. on desktop, mobile, and the Google app, lets users see what an item, say a top, looks like on a diverse set of real models ranging in size from XXS to 4XL, including how the item would drape, fold, or form wrinkles and shadows.

Generative AI’s arrival has led to many experiments in online search capabilities, including Walmart’s introduction of its first generative AI shopping assistant in partnership with Microsoft in January. Amazon’s first AI-powered shopping assistant, called Rufus, was released in beta in February.

A survey of 462 U.S. consumers from Constructor last year showed product search on retail websites scoring low grades with consumers. Among the findings: 

  • 60% think the online search function on retail websites needs an upgrade.
  • 30% said it takes at least three minutes to locate the item they need when using the search function on retail websites, while only 28% called their product search experiences “quick.”
  • When consumers shop with their favorite retailer, 34% said the site treats them like a total stranger each time they visit, presenting items that don’t reflect their preferences or prior purchases.
  • Topping the wish list of what consumers want out of product search was results that more closely reflect what they’re looking for, cited by 46%. This was followed by better filtering of search results, 41%; more personalized results, 34%; autocomplete, to accurately finish their queries, 30%; more integrated online and in-store functionalities, 29%; and the ability to type full sentences into the search bar and have it understand, 23%.

Discussion Questions

Which of Google’s personalization tools highlighted in the article likely offers the most appeal or practical use to online shoppers?

What are the biggest pain points product search on Google or retail websites needs to solve?

Poll

13 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Neil Saunders
Famed Member
25 days ago

I think there are some great tools here from Google. Search and personalization are two big areas where AI will play more of a role, and Google is getting ahead of the curve. That said, Google as a shopping channel is still very much second fiddle to marketplaces like Amazon. It will take more than better search functionality to change that.

Ashish Chaturvedi
Member
24 days ago

Google’s push towards more personalized online shopping experiences likely stems from a growing demand for more efficient and tailored online interactions, as highlighted by consumer dissatisfaction with current retail website search functionalities. This movement towards personalization is poised to set new standards in e-commerce, compelling retailers to adopt more sophisticated AI tools to stay competitive. However, this shift may also spark increased scrutiny around data privacy and the ethical use of AI, potentially leading to more stringent regulations and a call for greater transparency in how personal data is used to shape online shopping experiences.

Michael Zakkour
Active Member
23 days ago

I see GENAI for product search as having the most appeal. Virtual try-ons can easily be added to almost any site and I don’t see a “wow” factor in brand preferences. I think getting visual product search and GENAI connected will be a wow factor.

Melissa Minkow
Active Member
22 days ago

I love search improving, and I know this will broadly be appreciated considering how intentional most are now when shopping.

Lucille DeHart
Active Member
22 days ago

Since Google is a search engine, I see the generative AI product search tool as the clear winner. Visual search is a great innovation for the typical type and search. Seeing products and variation based on what you thought was your original intent can expand related offerings. When 60% of responders say they think retail sites need better search functionality and 30% say it takes too long to find a product, this AI function solves for both.

Shep Hyken
Trusted Member
22 days ago

What I like about the personalization tool is that the user gets to create their own profile with thumbs up or down. Combine that with other behaviors, and you can make Google your own personal shopper.
One important option is to let Google know when you’re buying something for someone else. There will be times when the personalization tool needs to be turned off.

Scott Norris
Active Member
Reply to  Shep Hyken
22 days ago

There also needs to be some kind of delineation within Google’s tracking between general search and shopping search. If I’m researching a competitor, that doesn’t mean I want to buy a t-shirt with the competitor’s mascot on it. I might look at a lot of locations for a potential vacation – that doesn’t mean I need clothing for all those places.

Jeff Sward
Noble Member
22 days ago

Is Google raising the bar…or…is the bar rising no matter what Google does? Sounds like Google is working extremely hard to prevent a loss of market share to ChatGPT and any other AI wizardry that is about to emerge. Google’s dominance in search is experiencing a lot of competitive exposure. And Amazon’s dominance is shopping has at least as much exposure as more and more social media sites become shoppable.

David Naumann
Active Member
22 days ago

Google’s piloting of new product discovery elements is a smart strategy to improve the product search experience. According to a study by Search Engine Land, Amazon (50%) is still the primary go-to place to begin product searches and Google (31%) is the second most frequent product discovery tool. It is hard to change consumers’ habits, but Google’s efforts to make product searches more accurate and quick, will potentially help shift some consumer’s search approaches.

Gene Detroyer
Noble Member
22 days ago

If Google has raised the search bar, will Amazon leapfrog it? Technology changes quickly. To be the best today is no promise for tomorrow. The next generation of search is already in the pipeline.

The problem is, and what is critical, that the tech giants’ search offerings will pull away from everyday websites. They will set a standard and expectation that few can duplicate. Ease of search will train shoppers to gravitate to the most efficient online retailers.

Brian Numainville
Active Member
22 days ago

Google has to do something in the face of increased competition that could impact their dominance in search. Take a look at Perplexity and you will see one challenge. As it relates to shopping, while Google may not be in the lead at this point, if you are casting a wide net to look for products and pricing, it is more useful than a singular channel search like Amazon.

Last edited 22 days ago by Brian Numainville
Dave Wendland
Active Member
22 days ago

Google is continuing to move the goalpost in terms of search — and it will ignite others to incorporate new ways to support shoppers and drive results.

Brian Cluster
Active Member
22 days ago

One of the biggest pain points in retail websites is wading through the endless thumbnail aisle. There are hundreds of miniature thumbnail pictures of options for any single item which can be overwhelming as a shopper. What compounds the problem is that many websites don’t remember your previous searches or you at all so you may have to repeat the same sequence of searches over and over again. It’s a mass search approach that doesn’t feel too personalized.
Google’s Generative AI with search options to generate pictures of a desired item or their Circle with Lens option to identify items in the physical world are welcomed innovations that can reduce the drudgery of search and get to options and answers faster for shoppers.

BrainTrust

"Since Google is a search engine, I see the generative AI product search tool as the clear winner. Visual search is a great innovation for the typical type and search."

Lucille DeHart

Principal, MKT Marketing Services/Columbus Consulting


"Google is continuing to move the goalpost in terms of search — and it will ignite others to incorporate new ways to support shoppers and drive results."

Dave Wendland

Vice President, Strategic RelationsHamacher Resource Group


"Sounds like Google is working extremely hard to prevent a loss of market share to ChatGPT and any other AI wizardry that is about to emerge."

Jeff Sward

Founding Partner, Merchandising Metrics