This is really, really simple.

A retail store is private property. Within the law, private property owners have the right to set whatever policies they wish for those entering their premises. This includes an obligation to wear a mask. If you don’t like those policies then you are free not to shop there and to go elsewhere. If you do want to shop there, you abide by the policies.

It is a great shame that so many people don’t understand this and are unable to show respect for retailers and the staff working there. Some of the responses seen on social media are plain ugly and downright criminal. It is both shocking and saddening to see.

Shaming is negative in almost any context. In the world we live today, confrontations like these will most certainly be captured on phones and posted. These acts of reckless ignorance are sad and disgraceful, and frontline employees should not be subjected to this type of abuse. The best approach retailers can take is to post clear guidelines at the entrance of their stores – no masks, no service. Period. Given how aggressive and emotional some shoppers feel about the issue, I urge retailers to apply additional security at the entrance of the store to minimize confrontations inside the store.

I have seen a lot of these videos over the past few days. In my state, the counties that have the largest renewed spikes in COVID-19 asked the governor about implementing a mask requirement for their county, and the governor has not denied any of those requests. As much as some people don’t like the requirement (especially at restaurants and gyms) people need to know there is value in wearing a mask to help curb new cases. I have also seen where customers have acted badly and taken it out on the employees — when the rule is not the employees’ fault. They are only adhering to the rules mandated by the county. Acting like a fool isn’t going to accomplish anything other than that person being slammed on social media. Stores need to continue following rules and monitoring that customers are adhering to them. Those that don’t or can’t should not be allowed into the stores.

In fairness, I’ve shamed shoppers at my local stores who do not wear masks, especially the idiot at Kroger the other day who was coughing and not wearing a mask. Regardless of whether people like it or not, it is an anti-social act to not wear a mask. Retailers should relish social media conflicts – it’s free advertising – as long as they are handling the problem as nicely and politely as the people at Gelson’s clearly did.

I am still for individual choice. We are all adults. This goes for both shoppers and store operators. We have the right to not shop at stores that do not enforce mask wearing. We also have the right to not wear masks. In rural areas, there is no shame nor much reason to wear masks. The news reports only on urban areas. This is not a one-size-fits-all situation. Even within the same state, Manhattan should have different guidelines than rural upstate NY. Trouble is, few elected leaders understand this.

Politicizing the workplace is never a good idea and, make no mistake, these incidents are political. Retailers need to obey local public health and safety regulations and have an obligation to protect both employees and customers. If that means making everyone comply with mask regulations, so be it. Now since retail stores have become the latest battlefield in the culture wars there will be customers that — for whatever reason — refuse to wear a mask and demand to be served. In the case of a genuine medical issue, shopping for a customer is the best alternative. Video shaming is never a good idea. Attention is exactly what most of these “mask protesters” want, and giving them digital air time just encourages them and others to continue their disruptive behaviors. In addition, it may make the rest of your customers worried that going to your store may result in appearing in an ugly Instagram post and create problems for your staff up to, and including, assault. So the best bet is to familiarize yourself with… Read more »

If a store has the right to say, “No shoes, no shirt, no service” — for public health reasons! — then it has the same right to expect its customers to wear masks. Neil is correct that private businesses should be able to exclude customers as long as the reasons aren’t discriminatory.

It’s sad that a simple, common-sense public health precaution was politicized to the point where customers are warring with each other, and with store associates just trying to do their jobs. Not wearing a mask, in a setting where you are asked to do so, is not some sort of statement about your political freedom — it’s just plain rude, and arguably dangerous given the rising outbreaks.

The retailers should follow their protocols, no exception. If a situation gets violent, they should do their best to de-escalate.

Otherwise I am all for the shoppers taking photos and videos of those who do not wear masks. There are consequences to decisions people make and if this is one of the consequences, so be it. You asked for it. You chose to be just plain selfish and have no regard for your fellow human beings.

And if that is not a good enough reason to wear a mask, Goldman Sachs just came out with a study that a national mask mandate could save the economy $1 trillion.

It shouldn’t be that difficult for people to express their own point of view AND have enough respect for other people to do the exact same thing. Don’t want to wear a mask? Shop at a like-minded retailer with like-minded customers. If you want to shop at a store requiring a mask? Pretty simple to put on a mask. It’s not exactly a hazmat suit. The states with discipline have a wildly different curve than states that thought haircuts and beach outings were the priority. Now who has more “freedom?” And who can expect a quicker and longer term rebound in the local economy?

Well, this may not be a popular opinion, but I am all for shaming those who don’t wear masks. This is not a matter of dressing poorly. It’s a matter of being a disease spreader.

Shaming is fine by me. I have no interest in dying to be polite. I reported an Instacart driver who was unmasked and tell anyone I see not wearing one in public to put one on.

It’s our only recourse to stupidity. Sorry.

I don’t think viral shaming will mean anything meaningful to the retailers. It will be a localized, minor disturbance at the time of the incident. We see the “customer from hell” type of videos from time to time. These are no different.

When talking to Aptos customers about how they planned to handle this, by far the majority opinion was that they did not want to force their employees to be “enforcers.” They would provide masks as much as they could to people who don’t have them, and they would ask people to wear masks, but would not take direct enforcement action unless store associates’ safety was threatened. However, with rising numbers of cases and the risk of infection spiraling out of control, the stakes are higher than ever. Masks are the reason why stores could possibly be open in the first place. I think retailers need to be very blunt and use a very large font on signs at entrances to set expectations: to come inside, you MUST wear a mask. If you’re not able to wear a mask, call this number and we will help you shop. If you enter the store without a mask, you will be trespassing and told to leave. If you do not leave or become belligerent, the police will be… Read more »

I frankly don’t get it, either one; the shaming or especially the refusal to wear a mask. The thing everyone has to realize is that it’s about being courteous and potentially (because who knows?) saving some lives or protecting others from severe sickness. Maybe less shaming and more explaining that it has nothing to do with “freedom” but more about someone not killing someone’s mother/grandmother. It feels like some education needs to happen more than anything. C’mon, America, let’s be civil!

The use of social media for public shaming, in general, is not great for our society. There is just nowhere that a line can be drawn as to what is acceptable and what is not. That said, retailers have the right to put policies in place that are best for their staff and customers. If there is no other way to get these people using masks as a political statement to get in line with policies (which, from what I’ve seen, seems to be the case), it’s a tool that must be used.

A retail store has the right to set the rules for entering their property. I see this as being similar to saying no shoes, no shirt, no service. The difference is the impact that not wearing a mask can have on the retailer’s other customers and staff. It is not political, it’s medical.

I suppose in some ways it’s an individual’s choice to take risks and get sick, but then analogous to those who won’t follow seatbelt laws, when they’re sick they take up scarce and costly healthcare resources. There aren’t enough Darwin awards for this crowd.

It’s not right to endanger others though, which is what going inside without a mask does. Reason doesn’t seem to work today — so maybe public pressure will. But in all cases stores could use a little help from the government to mandate masks and at least attempt to make it a universally encouraged behavior. It doesn’t matter whether you look at our COVID-19 statistics from the left or the right side of the page, it’s bad and it didn’t have to be so.

It is terrible that our front line retail workers have become the enforcers of this public health policy. If shaming people will discourage the bad behavior, then I’m all for it. The employees are just doing their job and enforcing company/local policy — it’s terrible to take it out on them. I get it. Masks are not fun, are not comfortable and no one WANTS to wear one. Best case scenario – you are at a reduced risk from catching or spreading a disease. Worst case scenario – you had to wear a piece of fabric on your face while grocery shopping. If it’s that hard, people do have the right not to go into public stores. So many retailers are doing a fabulous job with curbside pickup and delivery.

Retailers aren’t doing the shaming — mask-wearing customers are, and I’m all for it. No mask, no service.

This is simple and fundamental for all stores, restaurants, schools, and public places. Private and public organizations have every right to enforce mask-wearing to help prevent the spread of what has proven to be a very serious virus.

Health, safety, and security matter more than ever. The unfortunate viral videos of customers who refuse to wear masks are partly attributed to the lack of a consistent federally-mandated and enforceable strategy around mask-wearing. States and local governments have a varied approach to this, and it comes down to store owners and restaurants helping to regulate things to keep their associates and customers safe.

The pandemic has not only accelerated trends that were ongoing before the virus started spreading, but also the political polarization around masks or no masks.

How did we end up with so much vitriol in society?

Certainly the choice not to wear a mask is one which threatens people around you. So how did it become ok to ignore the health and well being of the rest of society in favor of (usually) embracing a facial individualism?

On the other hand, how did we so quickly forget there ARE reasons people can’t wear masks? Where did our sympathy for their conditions go?

The key here seems to be finding a middle ground where those who legitimately can’t wear a mask can signal “I care for those around me” while being mask-free.

Instead, we’re all shouting at each other. Sigh.

How many times has the “no shirt, no shoes, no service” policy been challenged by customers? Due to medical reasons? Retailers have the right to set policies for shopping in their stores. In most cases, they can also refuse service to shoppers who are in violation of their rules and policies. This is a time where retailers should absolutely hold their ground. Retailers owe it to their customers to provide a safe shopping environment, with fair prices, quality products and decent service. Nothing more. Still, many retailers are going above and beyond by providing an alternative for those who refuse to wear a mask like offering to shop for them (also, online shopping is a new invention that has worked for millions). Suggesting that store employees can’t shop for them because there are “private” things they want to buy is a farce. Store managers know and stock every item in the store. And let’s be honest, nothing is private at checkout. Bottom line is, the vast majority of customers who refuse to wear a mask… Read more »

This is a video showing the poor position people take in the service of trying to prove themselves right. What is the point? If you want to shop, abide by the rules. They are there to keep us safe. Like it or not. In this case, she only wanted to prove herself a better debater than the store security person. How intelligent is that? I saw something on Facebook last night. It was an ad from an attorney saying if you have been refused service because you would not wear a mask; contact us so we can prove how stupid (or words meaning the same thing) you are.

Humor is a coping mechanism and, as consumers see their peers behave increasingly erratically, it only makes sense that people would joke about it to keep moving forward.

The viral videos showing the chaos in grocery stores could turn off some consumers from physical shopping. However, it also shows that the retailer is enforcing mask mandates and has employees that can remain professional in any situation.

Instead of stressing about viral videos (which are generally out of their control), retailers should create a strategy to get their brand highlighted in meme culture. After all, it’s one of the primary ways that consumers build community remotely.

What Neil said. To elaborate: I’m entirely fine with intense social pressure (and mild legal pressure) on me and my fellow citizens to wear a face covering in public. In the present circumstance, when you approach me unmasked in public, that’s tantamount to an assault on my person. If your raise your voice and scream about it, thereby exhaling far more particles and sending them a much farther distance, that might as well be attempted murder. #maskitorcasket