DISCUSSION

Why Is Starbucks on the Decline, and Can the Situation Be Turned Around?

Written by RetailWire Staff

Starbucks has been on a recent decline marked by decreasing stock prices and a prediction of declining sales after an increase in November.

Concerns over Starbucks' recent sales slump — marking 11 consecutive days of stock decline and eradicating 9.4% of its market value (a loss of almost $12 billion) — have escalated among investors, according to Bloomberg. This downturn, noticeable in November, contrasted sharply with the 8% comparable sales growth in fiscal Q4. JPMorgan analyst John Ivankoe, in a recent note, downgraded Starbucks' Q1 U.S. comparable sales growth forecast from an initial 6% to 4%. Overall, Starbucks shares have fallen by 1.6% this year, contrasting with the S&P 1500 Composite Restaurants Index's 11% increase.

One of the major and most recently publicized reasons for this decline may be attributed to Starbucks' treatment of workers, their wages, workload, and desire for unionization.

Employees at Starbucks have been voicing concerns about their working conditions and have tried repeatedly to unionize. The Associated Press reported that since 2021, a minimum of 366 U.S. Starbucks stores have opted for unionization per the National Labor Relations Board. However, there's still no labor agreement between Starbucks and the Workers United union at these locations.

Starbucks has made every effort to deter unionization, and this may be harming both the company’s image and the morale of its employees. After Starbucks announced plans for a global expansion and increased wages for its workers in November, it specified that some of the benefits will only be available to employees who haven't joined a union, "despite a previous ruling by a National Labor Relations Board judge who found that Starbucks had violated federal labor law with similar measures.”

As a result, strikes have been popping up, and they have been costly to the coffee retailer — most notably the recent Red Cup Rebellion, which saw thousands of workers at over 200 U.S. Starbucks stores go on strike during Red Cup Day on Nov. 16.

The Public Perception of Starbucks

An additional detriment to Starbucks is how the public perceives the company’s image in response to recent news. Notably, on Reddit, many users from around the globe have been sharing their opinions, feelings, and observations about the company’s quality, pricing, and treatment of its employees.

Critics argue that Starbucks has compromised quality and shifted its focus away from customers through aggressive cost-cutting, increased prices, and uninspired design, which they believe is driven by a relentless pursuit of profit growth. Reddit users also highlight concerns about reduced wages, decreased store hours, and labor cuts. Furthermore, accusations of poor employee treatment circulate online, discouraging patrons from supporting such businesses.

Starbucks' Pricing Is Out of Control

Another important factor that many consumers have noticed is how Starbucks has continued to increase and inflate its prices on a regular basis. Many customers feel that these price increases are not justified and are more of a direct result of corporate greed. 

Reddit users regularly discuss how Starbucks' consistent price-raising practices are not only insulting but also unwarranted considering a perceived decrease in food quality and flavor. This has led some to consider alternative, upscale coffee houses that offer higher quality drinks at similar pricing or find cheaper alternatives that are improving their quality, like 7-Eleven.

Starbucks on the Decline

With the overall inflation and suffering economy, there’s no doubt that many consumers are also shying away from their usual Starbucks treat to help offset their holiday spending. However, there are many other aspects that will continue to erode Starbucks’ dominance beyond the holidays if not properly addressed.

Ultimately, Starbucks faces a multitude of challenges that result from consumer pushback due to rising prices, lack of innovation, and employer-worker issues.

Discussion Thread0

The RetailWire Daily

One morning briefing: the retail news, expert perspective, and business context to bring into your next meeting.

Want to know more? Learn more